Keith you are normally so spot on, but this is drivel, I don't know where you get your info from but having eviscerated the odd politician for poor analysis in the past I would have thought you could do better. For someone buying the leadership Cunliffe is wasting a lot of jobs by indicating most of his rivals would be on the front bench. I know Labour MPs voting both ways and I know some of them well enough to know that they are not voting on job promises. You are presenting yourself as an insider which you are not, this reads like a well scripted half truth of half the story.